Pravda comes to America

First, a Trip Down Memory Lane

When I was in college, back in the 1980s, I spent a week in the former Soviet Union. I was doing a semester abroad in London and my roommate got us onto a Russian tour – you could not go to the USSR from the USA due to diplomatic restrictions on traveling to enemy states but Americans could book tours from London to the USSR. This particular tour included mostly Jewish Americans interested in exploring a country their ancestors had fled. I was Irish Catholic (my mother was an Irish immigrant and my father was "South Side Irish" from Chicago whose mother claimed to be a Chicagoan of German Catholic ancestry.*) 

Here is a souvenir of my trip - which I still have stored in one of my cabinets:

                      Small bottle of some kind of Soviet-era booze purchased in the USSR in the 1980s.

Back in those days, the USSR was our biggest enemy, the reason we needed the largest defense budget in the world - we were constantly told we needed to bulk up our nuclear weapon stockpile or face being annihilated by the other global super power. The arms race was terrifying; we all knew that we could all die in an instant if one of the two leaders pressed the right button.

On that trip, however, I soon realized that the USSR was far removed from being "super" in anyway except in the number of nukes it had. We saw lines everywhere - people often didn't know what they were in line for, but figured they did not want to miss the chance to get something essential. We chatted with foreign students studying in Moscow, who were very disillusioned with their Soviet experience – care packages from home needed to include tampons and toilet paper. Are you really a "superpower," I wondered, if you cannot supply tampons and toilet paper to the populace? 

We talked with as many people as possible - though that was hard because it was a tightly coordinated tour, with tour guides. When we passed the stadium used in the 1980 Olympics, the female tour guide was nearly in tears over the pride she felt over how wonderful those Olympic Games were. All of Americans on this tour had no memory of the Moscow Olympics because our nation had boycotted them due to the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan. (We should have learned lessons from their invasion of this unconquerable land!) 

Everyone we talked to – Soviet dissidents, Soviet Jews, people on the street - no one trusted anything in the newspapers - news media outlets were state-run propaganda outlets. Pravda was the main paper and it existed to carry the lies of the politicians leading the nation.  

On that trip, we had late morning vodka shots in the apartment of a Jewish dissident – he asked if we could smuggle out his poetry because it could never be published in his home nation. In that I was the only non-Jewish person on the trip, I was the person selected to smuggle out his papers (all written in Russian) in my luggage. I was at the end of the line at Customs and imagine my surprise when I saw the scary-looking customs people (dressed in military garb) searching everyone else's luggage. I was terrified about what would happen when they found the dissident's papers in my bag - I had no idea what he was saying in his poems - would they get me in trouble? 

Fortunately, I was at the end of the line and I think by the time they got to me, they were bored - or maybe they knew I did not identified at Jewish* (see note below!)  - I'll never know why my luggage was the only luggage not exhaustively searched (thankfully.) When the plane took off, everyone on it, including the American civil servant sitting next to me heading home for a break, applauded, thrilled to be lifted away from the grim, authoritarian soil of the Soviet Union. I have never before or since flown on a plane where everyone applauded at the moment the plane left the earth. 

All this brings me to America today - are our media outlets turning into American versions of Pravda? 

Hawks or Hawkeyes? There is a difference...  

Several weeks ago, on Sept. 29, Axios carried a story talking about the political brilliance of GOP Sen. Eric Schmitt from Missouri – suggesting he was possible VP potential for a JD Vance presidential campaign in 2028. Coincidentally, on that very same day, Schmitt was scheduled to interrogate former DOJ Special Prosecutor Jack Smith about his work investigating Trump's actions to steal classified documents and incite violence at the Capitol on 1/6/21. Schmitt pulled out all the stops in his performance, all leading up to the "gotcha" moment where he was going to revel Smith's stunning corruption. Schmitt suggested that on February 3, 2026, Smith had gone to an Atlanta Hawks game to engage in some backdoor shenanigans with Fani Willis, the Atlanta prosecutor investigating Trump's attempts to overturn the Georgia election results in 2020. 

The big moment – Jack Smith colluded with Fani Willis at a Hawks game! – was amplified by a number of rightwing media personalities - including Sean Hannity, Benny Smith, Rich Sementa. Here's a screen grab of Hannity's tweet:


But then - and oh no for poor Eric Schmitt and his propagandists! – Jack Smith said that he WAS at a basketball game on February 3 – but it was a University of Iowa HAWKEYES WBB game – because Jack Smith is a fan of WBB superstar Caitlin Clark. In other words, Smith was nowhere near Atlanta or Fani Willis - he did not lie under oath – he was not, accusations aside, colluding with the Atlanta DA on how to put away Trump for fake crimes. 

And there were questions as to why Axios decided to publish a blurb on Schmitt's political brilliance on the same day and just moments before his self-inflicted PR disaster. What a weird coincidence!  

The rightwing media personalities all quickly deleted their "gotcha" posts, though the Axios story can still be found online. 

                 Axios blurb promoting Schmitt's VP potential moments before he embarrassed himself. 

 

But the damage was done. The "news" personalities were all promoting a GOP talking point before they realized how stupid it made them all look. 

What this moment indicates is that rightwing politicians collude with rightwing media personalities on their talking points. The ensuing noise that comes after a "gotcha" moment is hard to ignore and usually ends up providing the frame in mainstream news media for the news story being covered. 

With Schmitt's particular moment in the sun, however, he ended up looking stupid, as did "news" folks like Sean Hannity. But the initial "noise" about Schmitt's Jack Smith "gotcha!" drew back the curtain to expose the machinations of the rightwing media ecosystem. 

Missouri Guy Gets "Got" in Michigan  

Recently, Democratic senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed held a town hall meeting in Michigan to answer questions from voters. A man named Tommy asked if El-Sayed would disavow the Muslim Brotherhood, an international Islamist organization. Apparently, El-Sayed's mother was involved with this group – she left the family home in Michigan and moved to Egypt when El-Sayed was a small boy. There is no evidence (as far as I can find) that El-Sayed is in anyway an active participant in the Muslim Brotherhood. 

El-Sayed posted this exchange with Tommy on his socials on Oct. 17, 2026 - it's worth watching (and it's been viewed by thousands of people thus far.) He is Muslim and his religion has been the source of political attacks from Republicans, whose claims are then amplified in news media. El-Sayed, in his answer to Tommy's question, focuses on our constitutional right to express our religion freely, and he wonders openly why Tommy asked this Muslim candidate the question about his allegiance to the Muslim Brotherhood. 

Oddly enough, Jan Crawford, CBS News senior legal correspondent, picked up on this exchange almost immediately, and issue a tweet that praised Tommy for his question and bashed El-Sayed for his "diatribe," which in Crawford's mind, proved Tommy's point (not sure what point Crawford thought Tommy was making when he asked about El-Sayed's relationship with the Muslim Brotherhood.) 

                     CBS News senior legal correspondent reveals her extreme rightwing bias in this tweet 

Crawford's bias is revealed in other ways - she's the reporter that the rightwing SCOTUS justices like John Roberts go to when they want to share some propaganda.

CBS News bio of Jan Crawford, highlighting relationships with rightwing SCOTUS justices              Roberts and Scalia

Turns out that Jan Crawford was issuing "congrats" (her word) to a rightwing political operative who cut his teeth on working with Josh Hawley - yes, that Josh Hawley whose behavior on 1/6/21 showcased his support of the anti-constitutional and illegal efforts of Trump's base to overturn the election Trump lost AND his cowardice in the face of the violence of Trump's base at the Capitol that day. 

 

           The two faces of Josh Hawley on 1/6/21... supporting and then running from Trump's mob        

Independent journalist Marissa Kabas did a little digging after El-Sayed's video went viral and discovered that Tommy wasn't a Michigan voter concerned about the issues. Tommy was Tommy Teepell, son of Timmy Teepell, a rightwing political operative who worked for Bobby Jindal. Tommy, the young man who asked the question, has worked for Hawley and for Philip Sarnecki's failed run for governor of Kansas. 

Kabas' story, published on has also gone viral (support her work if you are so inclined!) What she uncovered is that the party that keeps screaming about how Soros pays Democrats to protest has actively engaged in using at least one political operative to ask a "gotcha" question at a Democratic town hall. 

Why was the senior legal correspondent for CBS News congratulating Tommy on his actions at the El-Sayed town hall? Why did she characterize El-Sayed's discussion of the Constitution as a "diatribe"? She seemed quickly to understand she'd stepped in propaganda doo-doo and took her tweet down. 

One might ask how appropriate it is for a news media outlet's "legal correspondent" to define a discussion of one's constitutional freedom of religion as a "diatribe." In any discussion of journalism ethics, her behavior is unethical in that her bias is on full display. But in her defense, the CBS News publishing principles are predominantly worried only about reporting that might lead to financial gains for the reporter: 

"Conflicts of interest exist when someone could profit personally or otherwise benefit from a decision they make on behalf of the company."

So I can see why Crawford would think that keeping her political bias a secret is not that important in her work. However even Crawford soon understood that offering up congratulations to a political operative for a gotcha question that was answered by the candidate with a lesson on our constitutional right of religious freedom was a bad look for a legal reporter and she took that tweet down. 

But the frame for the story in other media outlets became focused on whether or not El-Sayed disavowed the Muslim Brotherhood. Here's one from CNN:

                    CNN headline focuses on the GOP talking point, not El-Sayed's discussion of our rights. 
 

The New York Times doesn't even mention Tommy in their Oct. 21, 2026 story, published several days after Kabas exposed Tommy as a political plant, an interesting editorial choice. 

                                    New York Times story focuses attention on "attacks on his faith" 

So Tommy did good for his party – a number of news stories that filtered into mainstream news media focused on the talking point he wanted them to focus on.  

What we're seeing with these two examples is how rightwing operatives create noise of some kind that is quickly picked up and amplified by news outlets. These two situations were quickly exposed as propaganda tricks - but not until after some "news" personalities amplified the noise before the actions of those on the right were exposed as circus tricks. 

 Be wary of how legacy news media frames their stories. They often choose the path of least resistance - amplifying noise and propaganda instead of doing the actual reporting that shows the noise is just a bunch of disinformation disseminated to move attention away from the facts. Pravda has come to America and that is bad news for our democracy. 

____________________________________

 

*RE: I am actually 1/4 Jewish, which I discovered much to my surprise just a few years ago - my grandmother's claims of being a Chicago-born child of German Catholics were exposed as a lie years after she died (she was 100 when she died.) 

Oddly enough, when I was a college student on tour in the Soviet Union, our male tour guide kept asking me if I was Belorussian - I looked, in his mind, very Belorussian. I kept telling him I was of Irish and German background. MANY years later, we found out our paternal grandmother, who claimed birth in Chicago of German Catholic parents, was actually born in a shtetl in Tsarist Russia - in what is now Belorussian territory. Weird how things turn out! 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

On the failure of "the invisible hand" to influence our financial sector

John Roberts has ensured Trump will never be held accountable

How the New York Times whitewashes Trump's overt lunacy – an example